By Timothy Hay, WSJ Blog Post
Deal pace in the venture capital industry has cooled considerably. At the same time, demand for useful smartphone applications has heated up beyond the boiling point, as the billion-plus downloads logged by Apple Inc.’s App Store in less than a year can attest.
So it was probably just a matter of time before tech-savvy venture capitalists – whether for love, or for money – began developing their own phone apps, altering or even abandoning their traditional role of financial engine to eager entrepreneurs.
Ben Choi, for example, who this summer left Storm Ventures to take a position with Seattle-based venture firm Maveron, moonlights as an app developer and recently launched his first offering in Apple’s App Store.
“It’s so easy to do now, where it was almost impossible to do two years ago,” Choi said. “This is something I can do in my spare time, on my own Mac.”
While at Storm, Choi spearheaded investments in successful Web and mobile ad networks YieldBuild Inc., Adgregate Markets Inc. and AdInfuse Inc. He also worked with RRE Ventures, and with the CIA’s venture division, In-Q-Tel.
Choi’s first app, called Bean Cards, is a Chinese-language learning program geared toward toddlers.
“As I left Storm, this was a nice side project,” Choi said. He is bootstrapping a two-employee app company, Four Beans Inc., which he may present to Maveron or Storm if it blossoms into a good investment opportunity down the road, he said. He began building his app when he realized that babies and toddlers are fascinated by the iPhone, but that few apps have been created for them.
While the Bean Cards app might move to a premium-fee model, where users pay more for more features, it is currently staying afloat with the 99-cent download fee, which Choi said has been paid hundreds of times since its June launch.
“I’m not quitting my day job,” Choi said, but he added, “I think this will make me a better investor.”
From Investor To Entrepreneur
Another venture capitalist, Dan Gellert, is actually taking the plunge. As he prepares to launch a travel-related application for the iPhone, Gellert has indeed quit his day job as associate partner in Time Warner Inc.’s venture division.
“I worked hard to get to this point, and I’m excited to take the jump,” Gellert said. “There has been a part of me that’s been jealous, as I meet these guys building companies. I’ll miss some aspects [of investing] but I won’t have any qualms.”
His colleagues at Time Warner told him to expect some lean years ahead, Gellert said, as exit opportunities for start-ups had all but evaporated with the country’s financial problems.
“This was just the right time for me to go, for personal and professional reasons,” he said. “We discussed the exit markets, and the next couple of years were looking to be tough…This is what I really want to do. It’s more intellectually stimulating.”
In his three years with Time Warner, Gellert took part in eight investments in digital media, gaming and cable networking companies, he said.
But beginning in early September, Gellert is a full-time app developer. His location-based application, GateGuru, is meant to take advantage of the billions of hours – and dollars – that travelers spend in the nation’s 85 largest airports.
GateGuru uses a smartphone’s location-tracking technology to determine which airport, and even which gate, a user is visiting. It pushes information about nearby amenities to the user’s phone. Users of the app can also rate and review businesses, Gellert said.
“I’m going to start it lean, and bootstrap it myself,” he said.
Like Choi, Gellert has hired several software developers to help with his app. He plans to grow the company gradually, so that it does not outpace the app’s base of users.
When it launches at the end of September, a basic version of GateGuru with information on 20 airports will be available for the iPhone for a one-time, $1.99 fee, Gellert said. An expanded version – featuring the country’s top 85 airports – will also launch at that time, and can be had for $3.99.
The plan to monetize goes beyond download fees. As soon as the app attracts a large group of users, Gellert plans to offer coupons for some of the businesses located in airports.
Mobile couponing, a nascent idea but one that is anticipated by many to be a moneymaker, has become more feasible with the iPhone’s latest software update, which adds a secure payment mechanism for the device that is tailored for small transactions.
“If I look back 10 years from now, I’ll say this was the first scalable success for mobile coupons,” Gellert said.
More Opportunities For Aspiring Developers
The iPhone has something else going for it that has turned thousands of people, including venture capital professionals, into aspiring developers: an open, available software toolkit for building applications.
“The beautiful thing about the iPhone is the opportunity for small-time developers. Kudos to Apple for opening up the software,” said Ben Jabbawy, an associate at Nantucket-based GreatPoint Ventures, a seed-stage firm that often incubates young companies and puts its VCs in top management positions.
Jabbawy and GreatPoint founder Avi Goldberg have teamed up with other GreatPoint investors and software developers to launch Tiverias Apps Inc., a start-up app company that just released its first offering.
It took only a few weeks to go from concept to working app once a few developers were brought on board, Jabbawy and Goldberg said. The 99-cent app, called Gpush, remedies problems that the iPhone presents to users of Gmail. Released in late August, the app provides a shortcut to Gmail accounts. It was downloaded 25,000 times on the day it went live, the investors said.
Tiverias Apps will soon launch a business-utility app for the device, they said.
Following the firm’s usual investment strategy, GreatPoint will finance Tiverias Apps and seek to bring other investors aboard. In the past GreatPoint has co-invested in young companies with top-name firms like Khosla Ventures, Draper Fisher Jurvetson and Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, the VCs said.
“In most cases, we started the companies, mitigated the market risk and brought in senior leadership,” Goldberg said.
A Boom Waiting To Happen
The state of the mobile technology industry today has been likened by many to the state of Internet technology in the mid-1990s: a fast-growing, wide-open field where the rules are still being written.
From a VC fund-raising perspective, there have been a few successes among app developers. One is games and networking app maker Tapulous Inc., which raised $2 million from Khosla Ventures and individual backers before going live last summer.
But while mobile-industry analysts like Jupiter Research have predicted that mobile apps will bring in a collective $25 billion annually by 2014, the flow of investment dollars and revenue to app developers has been slower than many expected.
One of the main reasons for this is that Apple’s App Store, which features tens of thousands of apps, is still developing ways to help consumers find the kinds of programs they want. The number of paid downloads will increase when users are offered appropriate apps without having to search very hard, investors said. Apple and other tech companies are working hard on the discovery issue, and improvements to the system are expected fairly soon, investors said.
Phone makers like Research in Motion Ltd. and Palm Inc. have also built app storefronts for smartphone programs – another development that has the potential of speeding up the flow of dollars into mobile tech start-ups.
Top funds like the $100 million Kleiner iFund and the $150 million BlackBerry Partners Fund could ramp up, and put the lion’s share of the funds – which has not happened so far – into app developers.
While the number of successful, independent app developers earning a good income can still be counted on one hand, this could change sooner, rather than later, investors said.
“If we’re still in the same place three years from now,” Maveron’s Choi said, “I’ll be floored.”